Mac OS X Benchmark: native vs virtualized

An important thing about my work-in-progress virtualized workstation setup is that I've created the Mac OS X VM using my very own hard drives, hooked as raw devices (RDM: raw device mapping). So I can boot exactly the same OS directly from the hard drive, or from ESXi into a virtual machine. Quite convenient when the time comes to make comparisons. And now, I can boot the VM with ATI Radeon graphics card plugged in passthrough mode thanks to VMware DirectPath I/O and some tweaking.
While it's not enough to make a workstation (still miss a keyboard/mouse in passthrough), it allows some benchmarks. I've ran XBench on the VM and on the same OS booted natively from the hard drive.

The VM is configured with only 4 CPU. the Mac Pro sports a quad core Xeon capable of hyperthreading, so when Mac OS X boots natively it sees 8 CPU. It might explain the 50% difference on the Thread test, but that will require further testing.

The final result is not good at all. I understand very well that virtualization has a performance cost, but if I want a powerful virtualized workstation I need a setup that will waste as few resources as possible.
Quartz Graphics and User Interface tests show that "desktop" graphics are well supported, but the OpenGL test results are horrendous. With a performance loss of 87%, it predicts much trouble with games. According to this very simple benchmark, the VMware passthrough mode for graphics card seems to be very bad compared to what can be seen on XEN for example.
To be honest, having my hard disks accessed directly via RDM, I though I would have a 10-15% penalty. The 46% drop for sequential access surprises me. As for the GPU, the OpenGL results are so bad I'm wondering if the graphics card is properly passed through. May be some features are just dropped in the process. By the way, the virtualized Mac OS X won't load the screen color profile. May be it's related to the pseudo-VGA screen attached to the VSphere console. Unfortunately I can't get rid of this pseudo-VGA screen yet. Until I find a way to pass keyboard and mouse through to the VM, I need the VSphere console.

Results 259,39 127,18 -50,97 %
System Info
Xbench Version 1,3 1,3
System Version 10,6,8 (10K549) 10,6,8 (10K549)
Physical RAM 24576 MB 12288 MB
Model MacPro5,1 VMware7,1
Drive Type WDC WD1001FALS WDC WD1001FALS (ATA)
CPU Test 205,42 200,27 -2,51 %
GCD Loop 314,75 16,59 Mops/s 305,66 16,11 Mops/s -2,89 %
Floating Point Basic 182,81 4,34 Gflop/s 177,44 4,22 Gflop/s -2,94 %
vecLib FFT 121,5 4,01 Gflop/s 119,14 3,93 Gflop/s -1,94 %
Floating Point Library 385,38 67,11 Mops/s 374,17 65,15 Mops/s -2,91 %
Thread Test 954,74 477,33 -50,00 %
Computation, 4 thr. 989,65 20,05 Mops/s 517,69 10,49 Mops/s -47,69 %
Lock Contention, 4 thr. 922,22 39,67 Mlocks/s 442,8 19,05 Mlocks/s -51,99 %
Memory Test 452,72 370,19 -18,23 %
System 493,4 452,74 -8,24 %
Allocate 746,78 2,74 Malloc/s 877,63 3,22 Malloc/s 17,52 %
Fill 352,03 17116,62 MB/s 287,47 13977,29 MB/s -18,34 %
Copy 526,18 10867,96 MB/s 497,95 10285,00 MB/s -5,37 %
Stream 418,24 313,1 -25,14 %
Copy 422,51 8726,77 MB/s 321,23 6634,92 MB/s -23,97 %
Scale 395,84 8178,02 MB/s 303,88 6278,02 MB/s -23,23 %
Add 438,89 9349,24 MB/s 328,71 7002,18 MB/s -25,10 %
Triad 417,99 8941,89 MB/s 300,37 6425,59 MB/s -28,14 %
Quartz Graphics Test 315,19 300,47 -4,67 %
Line [50% α] 239,24 15,93 Klines/s 232,29 15,47 Klines/s -2,91 %
Rectangle [50% α] 314,61 93,93 Krects/s 296,25 88,45 Krects/s -5,84 %
Circle [50% α] 264,41 21,55 Kcircles/s 251,89 20,53 Kcircles/s -4,74 %
Bezier [50% α] 279,29 7,04 Kbeziers/s 263,55 6,65 Kbeziers/s -5,64 %
Text 875,44 54,76 Kchars/s 836,28 52,31 Kchars/s -4,47 %
OpenGL Graphics Test 306,01 39,01 -87,25 %
Spinning Squares 306,01 388,19 frames/s 39,01 49,49 frames/s -87,25 %
User Interface Test 463,72 405,19 -12,62 %
Elements 463,72 2,13 Krefresh/s 405,19 1,86 Krefresh/s -12,62 %
Disk Test 97,42 72,35 -25,73 %
Sequential 176,21 94,27 -46,50 %
Uncached Write [4K blk.] 180,38 110,75 MB/s 167,14 102,62 MB/s -7,34 %
Uncached Write [256K blk.] 177,43 100,39 MB/s 80,84 45,74 MB/s -54,44 %
Uncached Read [4K blk.] 149,41 43,73 MB/s 51,88 15,18 MB/s -65,28 %
Uncached Read [256K blk.] 207,16 104,12 MB/s 208,09 104,59 MB/s 0,45 %
Random 67,32 58,7 -12,80 %
Uncached Write [4K blk.] 21,3 2,25 MB/s 19,86 2,10 MB/s -6,76 %
Uncached Write [256K blk.] 507,04 162,32 MB/s 300,75 96,28 MB/s -40,69 %
Uncached Read [4K blk.] 159,73 1,13 MB/s 96,75 0,69 MB/s -39,43 %
Uncached Read [256K blk.] 235,97 43,79 MB/s 242,2 44,94 MB/s 2,64 %

À lire aussi :

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse de messagerie ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *

Ce site utilise Akismet pour réduire les indésirables. En savoir plus sur comment les données de vos commentaires sont utilisées.